109 Hill Rd NPickerington, OH 43147

Insurance professionals that have your back

Call Us 614-833-0555


We are happy to assist you in selecting the best coverage.

Get a Quote


We get you the right coverage for the right price.

Get a Quote


We offer free quotes and dedicated personal service.

Get a Quote

Welcome to Gibson Insurance Agency

We’re an independent insurance agency that delivers customized solutions to suit your individual needs. We’ve served individuals, groups, and small-to-medium sized businesses in Pickerington, Lancaster, and communities throughout Central Ohio for more than 30 years. We work with a number of A-rated carriers, and therefore can offer a wide variety of coverages. For this reason, there is virtually no one and no business that we can’t keep secure.

Insurance Forms

Insurance offerings that fit, and the experience to help match them with your individual needs

We understand that no single policy is right for every person. Since opening in 1981, we’ve focused on identifying our clients’ individual needs. As an independent agency, we can now help meet those needs at even more competitive prices. Operating as a single agency from two locations means that our clients have more ways to reach us in person or by phone. Many of our carriers also offer smart phone apps and web-based service which allow you to view, pay, and make changes to your policies 24/7.

Licensed insurance representatives keeping you secure

We know how important it is that individuals and businesses be secure, and to have insurance agents that help individuals and businesses through claims processes. This is one reason why we thoroughly assess the needs of individuals and of business owners, and it’s also one reason why we assist individuals and business owners through claims processes.

We quickly respond to clients, and also, in order to ensure that coverages are always current, and that the rates that people whom we serve pay are always competitive, we perform annual ‘care’ reviews, and we monitor premium change reports. If and when possible, we include the people whom we serve in care review processes. As a result, people whom we serve can fully understand their purchases, and be aware of needs for changes to coverages.

Contact us or call us today!

What Our Clients Say Testimonial Review Stars

They are very helpful and willing to listen and have always taken the time to answer our questions. If you are shopping for insurance I would sincerely recommend Gary Gibson Insurance!


They are awesome people to work with on all your insurance needs.


Love this place! My agent is so helpful and very responsive! Handled my claim amazingly! Thank you!


Leave Us a Review

The greatest testament that our customers can provide is by sharing their experience.

View More
Dairyland Logo
Foremost Logo
Hagerty Logo
Nationwide Logo
Progressive Logo
SafeCo Logo
State Auto Logo
Wyandot Mutual Logo